This seems to be the topic of discusion since The Inauguration, and Ive got to say.....Big Probs, Little Probs! Even if she did lip sync, you still got chills and it was beautiful!! Remember Whitney Houstons National Anthem at the Superbowl? It went down in history of being one of the best, it was lip synced!!! Still beautiful!!!
Here is the latest from Mailonline.........
Beyonce was widely praised for her live rendition of the National Anthem at the inauguration ceremony but now it appears that her performance may have been lip synched.
A spokesman for the Marine Corps Band who provided the musical accompaniment for the song said midday Tuesday that she did not in fact sing in real time, instead opting for a pre-recorded track of the song.
Hours later, a Marine spokesman backed off the claim and insisted he didn't know one way or the other, 'no one in the Marine Band is in a position to assess whether it was live or pre-recorded.
Earlier Tuesday Master Sgt. Kristin duBois said the band was notified at the last minute that Beyonce would use a pre-recorded voice track.
SCROLL DOWN FOR VIDEO
'She did a beautiful job with the pre-record': Beyoncé has yet to comment on reports she mimed during her performance of the Star Spangled Banner at President Obama's second inauguration ceremony, but Aretha Franklin has made her feelings clear
Officials stated that Beyonce decided to use the version of the National Anthem that she pre-recorded with the Marine Corps Band in the days prior to the Inauguration, but later backtracked
But later Marine Corps spokesman Capt. Gregory Wolf said that because there was no opportunity for Beyonce to rehearse with the Marine Band, it was determined that a live performance by the band was ill advised.
Instead they used a pre-recorded track for the band's portion of the song.
'Regarding Ms. Knowles-Carter's vocal performance,' Wolf's statement continued, 'no one in the Marine Band is in a position to assess whether it was live or pre-recorded.'
A representative for Beyonce did not respond to requests for comment.
DuBois declined to answer further questions. Earlier in the day, she told The New York Times that the rest of the inaugural performance was live and they did not know why a recorded track was used for the national anthem.
'It's not because Beyonce can't sing. We all know Beyonce can sing. We all know the Marine Band can play,' she said.
The news that Beyonce may been lip synching comes as a shock since she went to such an effort to pretend as if she was singing live.
Hints of a lie: Beyonce posted multiple pictures to her blog of the process by which she recorded the track
Better inside? It was revealed today that it was Beyonce's choice whether or not to use the recorded track
Behind the scenes: The track was recorded with the Marine Corps Band, and even they did not actually play at the ceremony
The most dramatic moment came when the Grammy-winner ripped out her earpiece mid-song- a move that many singers do when the bounceback in the sound system goes haywire and they are unable to hear themselves correctly.
Members of the Marine Corps Band confirmed that Beyonce did not spend more than one night preparing for the event, as she only spent the night before the Monday performance in the capital.
By contrast, Kelly Clarkson flew in several days earlier- and she ended up performing live rather than using the pre-recorded track that she made with the band.
'We had Kelly in over the weekend to rehearse and record. Beyonce, she's getting ready for the Super Bowl, so we didn't have a chance to do anything with her until last night so it's a very, very tight window of opportunity,' Marine Corps Band director Colonel Michael J. Colburn told Buzzfeed.
'As soon as we get information from the presidential inaugural committee who the guest artists are going to be, we make contact with them, find out how we can prepare arrangements that will really kind of flatter their voices — of course in the right key.'
Beyonce did not stay around to soak in the immediate praise from the performance either, as she reportedly flew back to New Orleans on Monday evening to return to Super Bowl preparations.
Though the millions of people who watched the inauguration were kept in the dark about the fake performance, many in the audience apparently knew that something was awry.
Raw talent: Kelly Clarkson, who performed My Country Tis of Thee, sang live during the ceremony and opted against using the pre-recorded track that she also had as an option
Friendly competition: Kelly Clarkson posted this picture to Twitter, being very complimentary of Beyonce
Lip synching songs is tool that strikes a controversial chord among performers.
Though it is generally accepted at certain large outdoor events (like the Inauguration, say) because weather conditions can be contentious and techincal difficulties could ruin the show.
That said, many performers consider it to be 'cheating' as fans expect that to hear a live performance.
Elton John and Madonna have an infamous, long-standing fued started when he was repulsed by the fact that she won the Brit Award for best live act in 2004. 'Since when has lip-synching been live?' he said in response to her win.
That same year, Ashlee Simpson famously flubbed when it was revealed that she was lip-synching because she pretended to sing when the wrong track was playing. After initially blaming her band, she later admitted that she had acid reflux and had been advised by her doctor not to use her voice.
The Washingtonian reports that many members of the press- who were seated directly below the podium where Beyonce was 'singing'- observed that the musicians in the Marine Corps Band were not actually playing their instruments during the song.
Instead, they were pretending blow into their instruments, even as their conductor carried on by visually directing the band. His performance, however, was mostly for the cameras.
Even Beyonce hinted that she would not be performing live as she posted a series of pictures of herself singing the Star Spangled Banner in a recording studio with the Marine Corps Band in the days leading up to the ceremony.
The Times of London confirmed the rumor and spoke directly to an unnamed spokesman for the band who said that inaugural performances are always pre-recorded as a precaution, but it is left up to the artist themselves if they would like to use the safety net or go live. Beyonce apparently chose the former.
'We did pre-record it and it was Beyoncé’s decision at the last minute to go with the pre-recorded version,' the spokesman said to The Times.
'This is our 54th inauguration… There is no question of there not being any music – it’s not because the performer cannot do it.'
That is certainly the case when it comes to Kelly Clarkson, who performed before Beyonce and decided to forgo the prepared back up by actually singing live.
The prospect of using pre-recorded music is not unusual: at President Obama's first inauguration in 2009, famed cellist Yo Yo Ma opted to have the recorded version of the song blasted on the speakers down the Mall and played in television broadcasts.
What was the point: If Beyonce was not actually singing at the time of the broadcast, then she would not have needed to rip out her earpiece as she did so dramatically in the middle of her performance
Nerves: The singer is a strong supporter of President Obama and has performed at a number of events for him in the past, most notably she sang the First Couple's first dance at the 2009 inauguration
That said, he still performed live in addition to using the back-ups.
'A broken string was not an option. It was wicked cold,' he said to The New York Times following the performance.
This is not the only time that Beyonce has been haunted by claims that she did not actually sing when she claimed to: in the 2009 Academy Awards, she starred in a musical number with the show's host, Hugh Jackman, and many believed that she did not actually sing.
The event's organizers did not clarify, either, saying only: 'As is the case with any live event of this scale and scope, there are always elements of the show that are pre-recorded. But I will not go into detail about which elements were on this show.'
Calls to Beyonce's press representatives from MailOnline were not immediately answered.
The singers' next major live performance will be at the Superbowl in New Orleans on Feburary 3.
Return to: Erin's Old Blog Blog